Category Archives: Commentary

Commentary on tournaments and debates, like flows, critiques, notes

Notes on the January 27 Clemency Topic

Happy 2018!

With three weeks of school before our next debate tournament, we thought it might be helpful to share some ideas regarding our next topic with all of you.  The motion for January 27 is:

This House would eliminate executive pardons and commutations.

A very successful former high school debater, now in college has generously provided some notes on the motion, which you can download here:  Notes On January 27 CTMSDL Motion .

The notes discuss plans and counterplans relative to the topic, and provides a useful set of references.

As always, please don’t hesitate to contact us if you have any questions or concerns.

Notes on November’s Scrimmages

For a number of years I have been writing commentary about Connecticut Debate Association topics and debate.  You can find this material through the CDA Training Material page.

I’d like to extend this practice to the Middle School League.  This, Scrimmage Commentary Nov14, is my first effort, based on the demonstration debates at our Novice Scrimmages at Bethel and Smith Middle Schools.

There is a brief discussion of three topics:  taking notes, defining terms and covering arguments.  I also include a summary of my notes for each of the demo rounds, so your students can see examples of what debate notes might look like.

If you find this material useful, you should feel free to make copies and share it with your students as you see fit.  If you notice any mistakes, or have any suggestions for improvement, please email me.

Everett